This June, we’re celebrating Pride Month and recognizing diverse voices in the judiciary. The following features 16th Judicial Circuit Judge John Dalton and his reflections on his career, diversity on the bench, and more.
What inspired you to become a lawyer, and eventually become a judge?
It was suggested by a neighbor that I’d make a good lawyer when I was about 7 years old. At that time, I felt the lawyer in Miracle on 34th Street was cool, so I thought it was a good idea. As I grew up, others encouraged the idea, and becoming a lawyer became my goal. I never changed my mind, worked hard, did well, and was sworn in as an attorney in the fall of 1987.
What accomplishments are you most proud of in your career?
I’m extremely proud to be a judge, of course, and as a lawyer I worked on many important cases, had many major clients, won significant civil rights litigation, etc. Along the way, I’ve been fortunate to win a number of awards for my work for equality, including the Martin Luther King, Jr. Humanitarian Award, and the ISBA’s Award for Community Leadership, among others.
What challenges did you face throughout your career, and how did you overcome them?
When I was growing up, one had no choice but to remain closeted (if one could) due to the overwhelming discrimination one would otherwise face. Openly gay people couldn’t get elected to any office, much less Judge. But, over time, great progress was made. I came out 34 years ago. It was scary then, but I don’t regret it. Over time, I gained confidence and found it within myself to stand up and object when I perceived discrimination against myself or others. I sought opportunities to work for equality. I faced discrimination at times, and still do. For example, the things folks said during my election campaigns was unbelievable. I was elected Judge in 2012, the first openly gay Judge in Illinois history outside of Cook County. Coming out is the process most responsible for the LGBTQ+ community’s progress towards equality. Living authentically and fully makes up for the hate some express.
Why is diversity important on the bench?
When a citizen looks at any significant part of their government, they should see themselves represented there. Representation is important to the judiciary being perceived as legitimate. Diversity brings different viewpoints, skills and attitudes, and is a source of strength in the judiciary.
How do you celebrate Pride Month and what does it mean to you?
Pride Month was not central to my coming out or my identity, but who doesn’t love a good parade? For many, pride parades and the abundance of flags and positive messages of support in June were important in their coming out process. Taking something once considered shameful and to be hidden, and celebrating it instead, is very powerful.
What are your thoughts on equality for the LGBTQ+ community and LGBTQ+ issues in the law?
So much progress has been made in my lifetime that I can hardly believe it. When I was young, the idea of gay marriage was inconceivable. My husband and I have been together for over 33 years, and we’ve been legally married since 2008. Recently, the community has been navigating a significant backlash, and many are afraid our hard-won gains could be stripped away. These fears are particularly acute for trans folks and people of color. I feel fortunate to live in Illinois, a state that has taken many actions towards equality and has worked hard to reassure LGBTQ+ Illinoisians that they are safe and protected here.
What advice do you have for young people in the legal profession today?
Be on time and be prepared. Seek a mentor. Network diligently. You will be great.